Note: Allpar does not take responsibility for the veracity of any information or opinions here, does not claim expertise, and is not responsible for any consequences. Please proceed at your own risk.
by Walt McCrystal
One of the earliest and simplest emissions control devices was positive crankcase ventilation (PCV), which doesn’t cost much, doesn’t hurt performance, and requires little attention. The system works simply by taking the unburned fuel vapors from the engine’s crankcase and directing them back into the airstream to be burned.
Originally, companies listed annual PCV valve changes in their owner’s manuals; now, they generally don’t. PCV valves usually don’t wear out, and are probably replaced far more often than they need to be as a matter of “preventative maintenance.” They can last for years and still do their job just fine.
The usual test for PCV valves is to shake them and see if they “rattle,” but some modern ones are spring-loaded and don’t “rattle” when shaken, so that PCV “test” can be invalid.
A good first test is to see if you can feel a strong intake manifold vacuum at the tip, with the engine at idle. Blocking the breather hose for a moment and then releasing it should show a vacuum has built up inside the engine crankcase. It should “whoosh” into the engine slightly when released; or hold a piece of paper, the stiffness and weight of a business card, at the end of the breather hose with suction.
If the crankcase pressure flow is the opposite way (blowby is being pushed into the breather filter, making it wet with oil), then the PCV apparently can’t keep up with the blowby. It can also leave an oil or moisture stain of the air filter. This may be a PCV, engine wear, motor oil quality, or low vacuum problem.
I have seen the PCV iced shut with engine condensation or restricted by heavy engine sludge. Some engines have heated PCV hoses to keep condensation from freezing. The PCV valve will close under turbo boost if there is an intake backfire events, because if a backfire flame were allowed to enter a crankcase, it could cause an explosion.
Staff: It’s easy to find PCV valves on the earliest engines, sitting on their own, out in the open, in the middle of the valve cover. On modern cars, they can be much harder to find and change, buried under the noise cover and then hidden towards the back of the valve cover and taking a nontraditional shape. On a 2006 minivan, they are on the back cylinder bank, underneath the cowl. In modern Pentastar-based cars, it can be hard to find, as seen in this video (which incorrectly calls it a “pollution control valve.”)
In the early 1980s, Mopar released a PCV valve that was heavily spring-loaded in the closed position on the carbureted cars. In the colder winter months, when engine crankcase blowby was heavier and the choke was on for longer periods of time, the high moisture content of the blowby vapors often iced up, blocked PCV flow, and would leave a stain on the air filter. In the shop, it became known as the “no-flow” PCV.
The PCV for the 6 and 8 cylinder engines was too much flow and would cause rough idle and stalling if used on the 4-cylinders, so using that valve wasn't a good option. The 2.2L turbos used the 6 and 8 cylinder style PCV without issues.
Chrysler released a PCV hose heater kit for the 4-cylinders that included a metal tube and a bracket that was held on by an exhaust manifold nut. This used exhaust heat to warm the incoming PCV vapors and hopefully prevent icing. It was an improvement, but didn't fix all of them.
The “no-flow” PCV valve was eventually discontinued and a more “moderate-flow,” softer-sprung PCV valve was introduced. That seemed to be a happy medium. The rough idle/stalling problems were reduced and the air filters stayed pretty much stain-free after that.
We strive for accuracy but we are not necessarily experts or authorities on the subject. Neither the author nor Allpar.com / Allpar, LLC may be held responsible for the use of the information or advice, implied or otherwise, on this site. This page is offered “AS IS” and without warranties. By reading further, you release the author and Allpar, LLC from any liability.
Jeep Wrangler history and production
Don Carlton racing cars
All Mopar Car and Truck News
FCA at the Eiffels
Chrysler: Port Melbourne