I installed this one. The black looks better and height seems to fit well also. So far in town it does ok.I have seen the rubber duckie-type short antennas.
It may be OK for local FM station reception. It may not do well out of town or on the AM band.
Advance Auto Parts - Down for Maintenance (at https://shop.advanceautoparts.com/p/metra-electronics-17-spiral-replacement-antenna-mast-aaprmoe/12005368-P?searchTerm=Antenna%20mast%20Metra )