[Dave Z]

First things first, the problem is almost certainly the starter (or solenoid or lock or transmission switch). First, make sure you have good heavy jumper cables. Second, try starting it from neutral instead of Park in case the issue is the switch. Third, if it still does nothing when turning the key, go to the relevant Allpar section and continue from there. If it was the ballast resistor, it would turn over but not start.

The 318 is in your favor as is being a Dart Sport rather than a Valiant four-door. When you say three speed, do you mean manual or automatic? Still it's not a terrifically valuable car.

Disclaimer: I have a 1974 Plymouth Valiant slant-six and have my eye on a 318 powered 1974 Valiant Brougham. And yes, selling's a good idea at this point. It really needs to be indoors and driven now and then

PS> If you want to sell it, for Heaven's sake, tell us where you are.

 

[Bob Lincoln]

His profile says CT. There is a decent market for these cars, especially if unmolested and relatively rust-free. I see too many of them for sale with body-painted bumpers, garish colors, big blocks stuffed in, roll cages welded in, etc.

This should fetch at least a few thousand dollars - pictures would be helpful.

 

[Dave Z]

That was my thought. FWIW, there's a guy in NE PA selling a mint 318 Valiant Brougham, but he might have arleady sold it, for $7,500. It's very low mileage (I think 12,000?) and looks new, inside and out -- looks far better than my own 14,000 mile Valiant.

 

[MRGTX]

First things first, the problem is almost certainly the starter (or solenoid or lock or transmission switch). First, make sure you have good heavy jumper cables. Second, try starting it from neutral instead of Park in case the issue is the switch. Third, if it still does nothing when turning the key, go to the relevant Allpar section and continue from there. If it was the ballast resistor, it would turn over but not start.

The 318 is in your favor as is being a Dart Sport rather than a Valiant four-door. When you say three speed, do you mean manual or automatic? Still it's not a terrifically valuable car.

Disclaimer: I have a 1974 Plymouth Valiant slant-six and have my eye on a 318 powered 1974 Valiant Brougham. And yes, selling's a good idea at this point. It really needs to be indoors and driven now and then

PS> If you want to sell it, for Heaven's sake, tell us where you are.

Dave,
Awesome information...Thanks so much for taking the time to wrote that up. It very well may be the switch...honestly, if the starter motor quit, I wouldn't be surprised. It worked incredibly well considering the age and amount of use.
I will try all of these things this weekend, assuming it stops raining for long enough.

The car has the 904. It would be interesting if it was a 3spd manual. Did they still offer that in 73? The only A-Bodies that I have seen with this transmission were '72 or older.

His profile says CT. There is a decent market for these cars, especially if unmolested and relatively rust-free. I see too many of them for sale with body-painted bumpers, garish colors, big blocks stuffed in, roll cages welded in, etc.

This should fetch at least a few thousand dollars - pictures would be helpful.

Thanks for this input, Bob. The car is solid...I am indeed in CT...the car lived much of its life (about half, I guess) in South Carolina which undoubtedly helped minimize the salt exposure.

The chrome is faded on the bumpers but they are presentable...and fortunately, I didn't have the money for the 440 swap that I wanted, otherwise this car probably would have been a pro-street/freak of nature like the rest of them.

If I could get anything like a few thousand for it...and it wasn't headed for the demolition derby, I'd be happy. I know it's not a rare collectable...

Honestly these A-Bodies are just good driving cars. As much as I wanted a fire breathing muscle car, it didn't really lack for anything. The 318 was always torquey and smooth...and it sounded great.

I'll clean it up over the next couple of weeks and post up some pictures. I'm not to big of a man to admit that I'll cry when this car leaves my possesion.

I really, really appreciate the input, guys.

That was my thought. FWIW, there's a guy in NE PA selling a mint 318 Valiant Brougham, but he might have arleady sold it, for $7,500. It's very low mileage (I think 12,000?) and looks new, inside and out -- looks far better than my own 14,000 mile Valiant.

That's insanely low mileage...for both of these cars. Amazing!!

 

[Dave Z]

They did indeed make three speed manuals in 1974, and indeed into the Volare years. Column shift and all.

If you really wanted to have something unique yet true, you could have that guy in PA put a light turbo on it. Or do it yourself, I guess! he posted instructions.

Yes, low mileage... mine was owned by a little old lady. http://www.valiant.org/valiant/project.html

 

[chuzz]

I had a 74 Duster with the slant 6, three speed manual shift in the floor. A former friend managed to total it for me one day. The engine lived on in a 67 Dart after that.

 

[valiant67]

A bodies are pretty hot and sportier versions (like the Dart Sport/Demon, Duster and Barracuda) are really doing pretty well on prices.
I had a heck of a time finding a 2dr Valiant that was in decent condition but not modified into a race car. Based on my shopping experience I think you might be able to get around $2k for it, but the price could increase if it's running. it may not be an easy sale at $2k non-running but it could happen.

 

[MRGTX]

Well... nearly two years have passed and the Dart is not only still in my possesion but it is getting some of the much needed/deserved love that it should have gotten 10 years earlier.

I just couldn't make myself sell it.

The original 318 is...shot. The motor is locked up, which certainly explains why it wouldn't turn over. I pulled the motor and I'm trying to decide what to do with it. It will need a full teardown/rebuild and while an all numbers-matching Dart would be cool, I'm ok with putting that on the back burner but any mods that I do to the car will be done in as reversible as possible fashion... So if the desire comes along, the car can be returned to stock.

I picked up a used "Magnum 300" 5.9L crate motor from a good guy on www.forabodiesonly.com... the A904 has gotten a rebuild with a TF2 shift kit, upgraded clutches, deep pan, external cooler, etc. I am working with the fellow who sold the engine to me on an A-Body width suregrip 8.75" axle...still trying to decide which ratio. The car now has a huge Champion radiator with high performance electric fans. Cooling should be no problem.

It's mostly back together (with the stock 7.25" axle....yikes) and my goal for this summer is to get this all together and get it running reliably. Next summer I will look into subframe connectors, and refreshing/upgrading suspension components, cam/valvesprings/headers, etc.

Thanks to all for the input on selling the car but I'm glad I didn't go down that path. This project is really making the long, dark winter a lot more tolerable.

 

[Bearhawke]

MRGTX: I hope you're aware of the external balance issues with the 360 and the need for a 360 only balancer and torque converter or at least a special flexplate unlike the '318' pieces.

 

[MRGTX]

MRGTX: I hope you're aware of the external balance issues with the 360 and the need for a 360 only balancer and torque converter or at least a special flexplate unlike the '318' pieces.

Thank you...and yes, I am. Finding the right flex plate was a bit of a pain in the rear since my use of the 904 is apparently bit out of the ordinary

The motor came with the weighted flex plate that went with a 727...but B&M has long since stopped making one for the 904...I ended up with a Dodge Ram 5.9L weighted flex plate that was the correct diameter for my trans, mated up to a neutral balance TCI torque converter with 2600 rpm stall speed.

 

[valiant67]

I don't think a well done 360 conversion would hurt value too much compared to the original 318. Of course, if you keep the original engine around just in case then you've got the best of both worlds. I loved the 360 powered 1967 Valiant I used to own. The 360 was mild (pretty much a stock rebuild of a 1974 E58 360-4) but the car was fast and fun.

 

[Bearhawke]

I don't think a well done 360 conversion would hurt value too much compared to the original 318. Of course, if you keep the original engine around just in case then you've got the best of both worlds. I loved the 360 powered 1967 Valiant I used to own. The 360 was mild (pretty much a stock rebuild of a 1974 E58 360-4) but the car was fast and fun.

The 1974-76 E58 360 motors; at least the ones with the old '340' cam (1975-76 non catalyst/dual exhaust) definitely would run and run well.