Joined
·
2,290 Posts
Jeep Commander, 2006-2010 and beyond
The Jeep Commander was dropped in 2010, and was at the time slated to continue as an offshore-only model produced in another country, because it could not be built on the same line as the 2011+ Grand Cherokee. This plan appears to have been dropped, with the 2010 Commanders being the last.
Talking about the Jeep Wrangler: Michael Berube and Don Renkert
Jeep Commander test drive
According to Jeep's Michael Berube, the Jeep Commander was the result of a decision to sell a three-rows-of-seats SUV. The three-seat desire expressed by many customers was not for permanent seating, but "in a pinch" flexibility - having to drive home two more kids or adults now and then.
The Commander was only two inches longer than the 2005 Jeep Grand Cherokee and was produced on the same assembly lines.
Donald A. Renkert, Senior Manager of the Jeep Studio, who was the principal stylist for the Commander (as well as Dodge Caravans and at least one of the second-generation Neons) said, "Jeep is not about being too big - we're not an intimidating brand. We don't want to knock down the trees, we want to fit between them. .. We said, let's embrace and celebrate the box. Let's not think outside the box, let's build a cooler box."
The windshield, windows, and doors all got straightened, providing more room inside, and giving the Commander more of a visual connection to past Jeeps. Informally, Mr. Renkert said that, while the styling does have some elements in common with Land Rover and the G-Wagon, that was not intentional, but the pricey SUVs helped justify the boxy shape to executives.
Mr. Renkert said they started with round headlights; some, though, felt the Commander needed quad headlights due to its price point. A design was apparently made using two sets of round headlights, echoing the 1960s Wagoneer, but this was not used. Renkert said, "We wanted people who saw it for the first time to say, 'Now, that's a Jeep.' ... We wanted it to look constructed instead of styled." They used Wrangler-like beveled edges and a clamshell hood, with fender flares bolted on using visible, chromed bolts.
Mr. Renkert said, "The Jeep Cherokee is an authentic, classic shape that is rooted in the public consciousness. By reinterpreting that vehicle, and other classic Jeep vehicles of the past, the Jeep Commander elicited nods of recognition from consumers, even though it is a brand new vehicle. There is a sense of deja vu about the Jeep Commander that brings knowing smiles of satisfaction."
Each row of seats was slightly higher than the one in front of it to make forward viewing easier. The second and third row seats folded forward to create a flat load floor.
The Jeep Commander had the same 4x4 systems, suspension, and powertrains as the 2005 Jeep Grand Cherokee including:
Trevor Creed, Senior Vice President of Chrysler Group Design, said the styling "springs from the archetypical Jeep vocabulary, executed in a more architectural and mechanical manner. This vehicle is clearly constructed primarily from the same aesthetic as two classic Jeep icons: the Wrangler and Cherokee."
There were two models: Commander and Commander Limited. The grille was body color on Commander, and chrome on the Limited. The Limited had D-pillar assist handles from the roof rail on down the back of the vehicle. The handles were black with chrome inserts in the grip area. The assist handles worked in conjunction with the non-skid step pad to help people gain access to the Commander's roof. In a twist, the rear washer was actually hidden from view inside the rear brake light.
Beginning over the second row, the roof was raised 3.15 inches to provide more headroom for occupants in the second and third rows. Viewed from either side, the stepped effect was concealed by a standard roof rack rail. The crossbar stanchions were similar to a buttress-style bridge support, and each side rail had three integrated tie-downs.
Seats were much firmer than the Grand Cherokee's, with dual-density foam; our initial thought on sitting in the Commander was, "I wonder if the park misses the concrete bench underneath this leather." Outboard seats had head restraints. The second row split 40-20-40 and the seat backs reclined. The third row split 50-50.
While the rear seats were easy to fold out of the way (with headrests that automatically fold to allow the seats to bend and pull-straps easily accessible from the rear), they were not especially comfortable to sit in, being only as far off the ground as their cushion height - not unlike the third row of seats on the Land Cruiser, but facing forward and being easier to move into place or back away again. Legroom for the middle and rear seats was adequate but not generous. Adults could fit in the rearmost row, but only for occasional use. Children, if they occupied that area, would be happy with the climate control vents for each row.
An L-shaped storage bin was in the load floor behind the third row seats. One side of the bin cover was carpeted and level; the opposite side was molded-in plastic, to stand up to dirty gear. Under the bin were the jack and tools.
Command-View skylights above the second row - fixed, tinted glass skylights - were sold with the power sun-roof above the front passengers. Each skylight had a roller shade to block out light when desired. An optional DVD player sat between the skylights.
The upper instrument panel was new, with 16 Allen head bolts (mostly functional) "contributing to the mechanical, constructed look." The gauge cluster was a carryover from the Grand Cherokee, supposedly inspired by the military Jeeps.
Performance
See our Grand Cherokee page for engines, four wheel drive system, and suspension.
The 545RFE, used with the V8s, was refined for higher-quality shifts; class-leading towing capacity of 7,200 lbs was equal to that of the Grand Cherokee. The Mercedes five-speed built by Chrysler was used with the V6. Both transmissions used Electronic Range Select (ERS) driver interactive shift control. An off-road group included a steel skid plates and all-terrain tires.
Safety included optional side air bags and electronic roll mitigation, and standard Electronic Stability Program (ESP); extended up-time side curtain airbags for all rows (they stayed active longer during rollovers); and various other features described in the Grand Cherokee page.
Jeep Commander on the road
This is a condensed version of the full Allpar review:
Specifications
The Jeep Commander was dropped in 2010, and was at the time slated to continue as an offshore-only model produced in another country, because it could not be built on the same line as the 2011+ Grand Cherokee. This plan appears to have been dropped, with the 2010 Commanders being the last.
Talking about the Jeep Wrangler: Michael Berube and Don Renkert
Jeep Commander test drive
According to Jeep's Michael Berube, the Jeep Commander was the result of a decision to sell a three-rows-of-seats SUV. The three-seat desire expressed by many customers was not for permanent seating, but "in a pinch" flexibility - having to drive home two more kids or adults now and then.
Donald A. Renkert, Senior Manager of the Jeep Studio, who was the principal stylist for the Commander (as well as Dodge Caravans and at least one of the second-generation Neons) said, "Jeep is not about being too big - we're not an intimidating brand. We don't want to knock down the trees, we want to fit between them. .. We said, let's embrace and celebrate the box. Let's not think outside the box, let's build a cooler box."
The windshield, windows, and doors all got straightened, providing more room inside, and giving the Commander more of a visual connection to past Jeeps. Informally, Mr. Renkert said that, while the styling does have some elements in common with Land Rover and the G-Wagon, that was not intentional, but the pricey SUVs helped justify the boxy shape to executives.
Mr. Renkert said, "The Jeep Cherokee is an authentic, classic shape that is rooted in the public consciousness. By reinterpreting that vehicle, and other classic Jeep vehicles of the past, the Jeep Commander elicited nods of recognition from consumers, even though it is a brand new vehicle. There is a sense of deja vu about the Jeep Commander that brings knowing smiles of satisfaction."
Each row of seats was slightly higher than the one in front of it to make forward viewing easier. The second and third row seats folded forward to create a flat load floor.
The Jeep Commander had the same 4x4 systems, suspension, and powertrains as the 2005 Jeep Grand Cherokee including:
- Three full-time four-wheel drive systems, Quadra-Trac I®, Quadra-Trac II® and Quadra-Drive II®
- Two transfer cases with Brake Traction Control (BTCS) and Electronic Limited Slip Differentials (ELSD)
- The 5.7-liter HEMI® V-8 with the Multi-Displacement System, the 4.7-liter SOHC Power Tech V-8, and the 3.7-liter SOHC Power Tech V-6 engine
There were two models: Commander and Commander Limited. The grille was body color on Commander, and chrome on the Limited. The Limited had D-pillar assist handles from the roof rail on down the back of the vehicle. The handles were black with chrome inserts in the grip area. The assist handles worked in conjunction with the non-skid step pad to help people gain access to the Commander's roof. In a twist, the rear washer was actually hidden from view inside the rear brake light.
Beginning over the second row, the roof was raised 3.15 inches to provide more headroom for occupants in the second and third rows. Viewed from either side, the stepped effect was concealed by a standard roof rack rail. The crossbar stanchions were similar to a buttress-style bridge support, and each side rail had three integrated tie-downs.
Seats were much firmer than the Grand Cherokee's, with dual-density foam; our initial thought on sitting in the Commander was, "I wonder if the park misses the concrete bench underneath this leather." Outboard seats had head restraints. The second row split 40-20-40 and the seat backs reclined. The third row split 50-50.
While the rear seats were easy to fold out of the way (with headrests that automatically fold to allow the seats to bend and pull-straps easily accessible from the rear), they were not especially comfortable to sit in, being only as far off the ground as their cushion height - not unlike the third row of seats on the Land Cruiser, but facing forward and being easier to move into place or back away again. Legroom for the middle and rear seats was adequate but not generous. Adults could fit in the rearmost row, but only for occasional use. Children, if they occupied that area, would be happy with the climate control vents for each row.
Command-View skylights above the second row - fixed, tinted glass skylights - were sold with the power sun-roof above the front passengers. Each skylight had a roller shade to block out light when desired. An optional DVD player sat between the skylights.
The upper instrument panel was new, with 16 Allen head bolts (mostly functional) "contributing to the mechanical, constructed look." The gauge cluster was a carryover from the Grand Cherokee, supposedly inspired by the military Jeeps.
Performance
See our Grand Cherokee page for engines, four wheel drive system, and suspension.
The 545RFE, used with the V8s, was refined for higher-quality shifts; class-leading towing capacity of 7,200 lbs was equal to that of the Grand Cherokee. The Mercedes five-speed built by Chrysler was used with the V6. Both transmissions used Electronic Range Select (ERS) driver interactive shift control. An off-road group included a steel skid plates and all-terrain tires.
Safety included optional side air bags and electronic roll mitigation, and standard Electronic Stability Program (ESP); extended up-time side curtain airbags for all rows (they stayed active longer during rollovers); and various other features described in the Grand Cherokee page.
Jeep Commander on the road
This is a condensed version of the full Allpar review:
Jeep Commander car review / test driveRoad noise has been well insulated, while the ride can be a busy but is generally quite good for a![]()
Rubicon-ready, off-road-capable truck. Fairly hefty potholes and bumps
are
handled well, especially in terms of sound: rather than a dull boom
or rattle, there is a
faraway-sounding noise of the wheel dropping in. The Commander has good
road manners, without the wallowing of some
trucks that try to make their suspensions soft, though there is some
jouncing at times.
Badly rutted roads were handled in stride, though other pavement
issues could get in; one particular washboard road, which gives trouble
to most cars and trucks (including loss of traction), felt almost
smooth in the Commander. Wind noise is practically nonexistent, and
engine noise is muffled well.
Cornering is![]()
surprisingly good, with a feeling of confidence around sharp turns; the
big Jeep seems very nimble and confident for such a heavy truck,
especially one boasting this much interior comfort and freedom from
shock The tires give audible notice long before grip disappears, but do not squeal excessively or prematurely.
Brakes are strong, as they need to be with the optional Hemi engine,
putting out 345 horsepower, albeit with the gas mileage you'd expect to
get from an engine of that power - the EPA overestimates it at 15
city, 19 highway, but we couldn't get near that (though we did achieve
15...on the highway). The engine responds
instantly under just about any conditions, moving the heavy truck with
alacrity but without excess noise. While 0-60 times are not
particularly impressive, the
instant-on acceleration is attractive. The five-speed automatic
transmission helps by downshifting rapidly, yet fairly smoothly; shifts
are moderately firm, but not mushy. Our one acceleration-related
complaint is the rather sudden tip-in, which is to say that it was
rather difficult to gently get just a little more gas while at highway
speed. The cruise control is very gentle, but shut it off, and it's
hard to avoid small driveline shudders.
Interior space is not much greater than in the Grand Cherokee, but
there are three rows of seats; both rear rows fold flat with easy, with
the back seats needing only a single lever pull to go from seat to flat
floor. Middle-row seating space is neither generous nor cramped, though
it gets cramped rather quickly if the automatic seat backup (for the
driver, to allow easier exit and entrance) is activated; third-row
seats have very little legroom and are clearly for smaller children or
short trips. The seats are excessively firm, as though made of concrete covered by leather.
Generally, controls were sensible and easy to use; the wheel-mounted![]()
cruise control had buttons in intuitive places, as well as a cancel
button, and all were placed within reach of the outside of the wheel.
On the back of the wheel were the various audio controls. Both passenger and driver have simple thermostatic vent controls
operated by knobs, with the temperature scales always staying in place;
the fan has both auto/low and auto/high settings, so you don't have to
subject yourself to the maximum possible fan speed just to use the
automatic fan setting, while ducting is set by a traditional knob that
allows you to pick zones between, say, full lower-vents and bi-level.
Above the climate control is the wonderful, traditional Chrysler
information center, with your choice of a thermometer/compass, gas
mileage or other vehicle information display, and a menu that lets you
set the car's various features, such as automatic headlights (on with
rain, staying on after the engine is shut, etc.), locking, and other
items that, in the past, had to be set by a dealer or by strange
machinations like turn the key on, press the locks, then wait, then
press the locks again, etc.
Using sensors
in the bumper, which can be a bit high, the car will warn you with
yellow LEDs if you are getting close to an object, like another car or
a cement wall or a small child. When you get very close, there's an
audible warning and red LEDs go on. (The LEDs are mounted in the roof
near the rear window so they can be seen when you're backing up,
assuming you're looking out the rear window).
Visibility is aided by strong headlights and big mirrors, and greatly![]()
hindered by the headrest of the middle-row seat, which blocks much of
the rear quarter - an area few modern cars seem to be able to keep
clear. The rear visibility is excellent when the back seats are folded
down, and poor when they are up. Large sun visors that can be pulled
out on their support rods keep the sun from being too much of a
nuisance; as befits a car of this cost, both driver and passenger get
mirrors that light when the flap is pulled up.
The storage area is decently sized, and the middle row of seats can
fold forward for more space. This is not a particularly large vehicle,
despite its appearance, and minivans will swallow up more people and
cargo.
Our test vehicle was not the entry-level Commander, but the Limited, which starts at $38,000 - a good deal more than the Grand Cherokee and Hummer H3 (which, by the way, offers similar mileage with 100 less horses), but less than the Land Rover LR3 and Hummer H2. This is a segment where prices are rather high, and you can pay a lot more without getting much more. The Commander is
competitive with similarly priced Toyota, Lexus, Land Rover, Ford, and
GM vehicles.
Specifications
AXLES / DIFFERENTIALS |